Bare Bar Ranked the Top Natural Soap in Independent “Manly Soap” Review (so far)
With the growing popularity of natural soap bars, more men are switching away from traditional shower gels and exploring alternatives made with natural ingredients.
Recently, an independent reviewer John at Geeky Gorevan decided to put some of the most talked-about soap brands to the test.
Instead of relying on marketing claims, John purchased and tested several well-known brands including Dr Squatch, The Black Stuff and us here at Bare Bar, documenting the experience in a detailed review titled “I Tried Every ‘Manly’ Soap Bar in the UK – Don’t Buy Until You Read This.”
The goal was simple: find out which soaps actually perform well in real use.
And so far, Bare Bar has come out on top. The review page is a live document and will be updated as the results come in.
What the Independent Review Tested
John at Geeky Gorevan approached the comparison from a very practical perspective.
Rather than focusing purely on branding, the soaps were judged on factors that actually matter when you use them:
- scent
- how the soap feels on the skin
- whether it causes dryness
- customer service
- scent variety
- ingredient quality
- value for money
These are the same things most people care about when switching from shower gel to natural soap.
Bare Bar’s Early Results
At the time of writing, Bare Bar currently holds the highest score in the review at 9/10, placing it ahead of the other brands tested so far.
The reviewer highlighted several things that stood out.
Most notably, the feel of the soap on the skin, which scored a perfect 10/10.
Many soap bars can create a slightly “dry” or tight feeling when washing, but the review noted that Bare Bar avoided this completely.
A Soap That Cleans Without Drying Skin
One of the key comments from the review was about how Bare Bar soap feels during use.
The Geeky Gorevan review explained that many soap bars create a “tugging” feeling on the skin when washing.
However, that wasn’t the case with Bare Bar.
Instead, the soap left the skin feeling soft and comfortable after washing, something that natural oils like olive oil, coconut oil and cocoa butter help achieve.
These ingredients help cleanse while maintaining the skin’s natural moisture balance.
Natural Ingredients With Real Performance
Bare Bar soaps are built around a simple idea: natural ingredients should still perform properly.
We make each soap bar using plant oils and natural exfoliants that provide a deep clean without relying on harsh detergents.
Ingredients commonly used in Bare Bar soaps include:
- olive oil
- coconut oil
- cocoa butter
- activated charcoal
- natural exfoliants like oats
These ingredients help remove dirt and excess oil while keeping skin feeling nourished.
Strong Customer Service Also Noticed
Another area where Bare Bar scored highly in the review was customer service.
After contacting the company with questions about an order, the reviewer noted that the response was friendly and helpful, scoring the brand 10/10 for customer service.
For a small independent business, that personal level of support can make a big difference.
A Growing Alternative to Shower Gel
For many people, switching from liquid shower gel to soap bars initially feels unusual.
But natural soap bars offer several advantages:
- fewer synthetic ingredients
- plastic-free packaging
- longer lasting products
- natural exfoliation
This is why more people are starting to explore natural soap options.
Independent Review Results
After reviewing soap brands including Dr Squatch & The Black Stuff, Bare Bar is currently coming out on top.
The soaps were evaluated on scent, skin feel, customer service and overall performance.
So far Bare Bar currently holds the highest score in the review.
In particular, Bare Bar scored 10/10 for how the soap feels on the skin, with John at Geeky Gorevan noting that many soap bars create a “dry tugging feeling”, but that Bare Bar avoided this entirely.
Explore Bare Bar Natural Soap
If you're curious about natural soap or looking to upgrade your daily shower routine, you can explore our full collection here:
Each bar is handcrafted in our studio in the UK using natural ingredients designed to deliver a rich lather, deep clean and long-lasting scent.
Final Thoughts
Independent reviews like this are valuable because they focus on real experiences rather than marketing claims. In world of more and more soap companies popping up, this review is extremely useful for people curious about the benefits of natural soap & what companies are doing it the right way.
While the review page is still ongoing and additional brands are being tested, Bare Bar currently holds the top score — something we’re incredibly proud of.
And if you’ve already made the switch to Bare Bar, thank you for being part of the journey.
Want to find out more about natural products and ingredients to look out for?
Natural Deodorant vs Antiperspirant: What’s the Difference?
Why More Men Are Switching to Natural Refillable Deodorant
7 Benefits of Natural Soap for Healthier Skin
Natural Soap vs Body Wash: Which Is Better for Your Skin?
Best Soap for Men: How to Choose the Right Natural Soap for Your Skin
Explore Natural Soap Bars & Refillable Deodorant:
If you're exploring natural grooming products, you can browse Bare Bar’s range of natural soap bars and refillable deodorants below.
natural soap bars
refillable deodorant
best natural deodorant
aluminium free deodorant
